Open Journal Systems

Establishing Causality in Medicine and Koch’s Postulates

Donald Angus Gillies

Abstract


This paper considers Koch’s Postulates for establishing causality, particularly in relation to his research on tuberculosis and cholera. In 1882, Koch showed that his claim regarding the tubercle bacillus satisfied all of his postulates, and this claim was then accepted by the medical community. However, he was not equally fortunate in his research on cholera. In 1884, he presented evidence in favor of the comma bacillus being the cause of cholera, but this evidence failed to satisfy one of his postulates; therefore, not all of the medical community was convinced with his research on cholera. Yet, when he presented more evidence for his views on cholera because of the Hamburg cholera epidemic of 1892, this view was finally accepted. This historical material suggests that Koch’s Postulates omit some types of evidence, which are important regarding causality. The postulates are, therefore, analyzed in light of some contemporary philosophical views of causality. Because of this analysis, a gap in Koch’s Postulates does indeed become apparent. It is shown that if the postulates are modified to fill this gap, they do then explain the acceptance of Koch’s views concerning cholera.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Evans AS. Causation and Disease. A Chronological Journey. New York, Plenum Medical Book Company, 1993: pp. 13–31.

Hare R. An Outline of Bacteriology and Immunity. 2nd edition, London, Longmans, 1963: p. 2.

Marshall BJ, Armstrong JA, McGechie DB, Clancy RJ. Attempt to fulfil Koch’s postulates for pyloric Campylobacter. Med J Aust 1985; 142: 436–439.

Illari P and Russo F. Causality. Philosophical Theory Meets Scientific Practice. Oxford University Press, 2014.

Koch R. Die Aetiologie der Milzbrand-Krankheit begründet auf die Entwicklungsgeschichte des Bacillus anthracis (The Etiology of Anthrax, Founded on the Course of Development of the Bacillus Anthracis). Beiträge zur Biologie der Pflanzen. 1876; 2: 277–310. [English Translation in K. Codell Carter,15 1987; pp. 1–17].

Koch R. Untersuchungen über die Aetiologie der Wundinfectionskrankheiten (Investigations of the Etiology of Wound Infections). Leipzig, Georg Thieme. 1878. [English Translation in K. Codell Carter, 1987; pp. 19–56].

Koch R. Zur Aetiologie des Milzbrandes (On the Etiology of Anthrax). Mitteilungen aus dem Kaiserliche Gesundheitsamte. 1881; 1: 174–206. [English Translation in K. Codell Carter, 1987; pp. 57–81].

Koch R. Die Aetiologie der Tuberculose (The Etiology of Tuberculosis). Berliner klinische Wochenschrift. 1882; 19: 221–230. [English Translation in K. Codell Carter, 1987; pp. 83–96].

Brock TD. Robert Koch. A Life in Medicine and Bacteriology. 2nd edition, Washington, D.C., ASM Press, 1999: p. 180. (1st Edition, 1988).

Gradmann C. Laboratory Disease: Robert Koch’s Medical Bacteriology. Baltimore, John Hopkins University Press, 2009. [English Translation by Elborg Forster] (1st Edition, 2005).

Thagard P. How Scientists Explain Disease. Princeton, Princeton University Press, Paperback Edition, 2000: pp. 39–97.

Carter KC. Koch’s Postulates in relation to the work of Jacob Henle and Edwin Klebs. Med Hist 1985; 29: 353–374.

Vonka V. Causality in medicine: the case of tumours and viruses. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2000; 355: 1831–1841.

Harden V. Koch’s postulates and the etiology of AIDS: an historical perspective. Hist Philos Life Sci 1992; 14: 249–269.

Carter KC. Essays of Robert Koch/translated into English by K. Codell Carter. New York, Greenwood Press, 1987.

Carter KC. The Rise of Causal Concepts of Disease. Case Histories. Aldershot, Ashgate Publishing, 2003: p. 248.

Gradmann C. A spirit of scientific rigour: Koch’s postulates in twentieth-century medicine. Microbes Infect 2014; 16: 885–892.

Koch R. Erste Konferenz zur Eröterung der Cholerafrage (Lecture at the First Conference for Discussion of the Cholera Question). Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift. 1884; 30: 20–49. [English Translation in K. Codell Carter, 1987, pp. 151–170].

Coleman W. Koch’s comma bacillus: the first year. Bull Hist Med 1987; 61: 315–342.

Von Pettenkofer M. Cholera. The Lancet 1884; 2: 769–771, 816–819, 861–864, 904–905, 992–994, 1042–1043, 1086–88.

Koch R. Ueber die Cholerabakterien (On Cholera Bacteria). Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift. 1884; 10: 725–728. [English Translation in Carter, 1987, pp. 171–177].

Evans RJ. Death in Hamburg. Society and Politics in the Cholera Years. London, Penguin, 2005: pp 241, 291–293, 599–605. (1st Edition, 1987).

Collingwood RG. On the so-called idea of causation. Proc Aristot Soc 1938; 38: 85–112.

Collingwood RG. An Essay on Metaphysics. Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1940, Part IIIc: Causation, pp. 285–337.

Gasking D. Causation and recipes. Mind 1955; 64: 479–487.

Wright GH von. On the Logic and Epistemology of the Causal Relation. In: Suppes P, Henkin L, Joja A, and Mosil GrC (Eds.). Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science IV. North-Holland, Elsevier, 1973: pp. 293–312.

Wright GH von. Causality and Determinism. New York, Columbia University Press, 1974.

Price H. Agency and causal asymmetry. Mind 1992; 101: 501–520.

Menzies P and Price H. Causation as a secondary quality. Br J Philos Sci 1993; 44: 187–204.

Woodward J. Making Things Happen: A Theory of Causal Explanation. Oxford, Oxford University Press, Paperback Edition, 2005: p.v. (1st Edition, 2003.)

Gillies DA. An action-related theory of causality. Br J Philos Sci 2005; 56: 823–842.

Pearl J. Causality Models, Reasoning and Inference. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2000.

Russo F. Causality and Causal Modelling in the Social Sciences.Measuring Variations. Springer, 2009.

Keys A. (ed.) Coronary Disease in Seven Countries. 1970; Supplement I to Circulation Vols XLI and XLII: 1–198.

Debré P. Louis Pasteur. Baltimore, John Hopkins University Press, 1998: pp 378–413. [English Translation by Elborg Forster] (1st Edition, 1994).

Koch R. Wasserfiltration und Cholera . 1893. Reprinted in Gesammelte Werke, 2/1: 183–206.

Gillies DA. Hempelian and Kuhnian approaches in the philosophy of medicine: The Semmelweis Case. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci. 2005; 36: 159–181.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18550/ijhpm.0603

Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM

Article Metrics Graph

Metrics powered by OpenJournalSystems.com

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
x
Message